Published by Summer Associates Tax Services, Stamford, Connecticut[email protected]
The Merchant’s Tax LetterTax planning for Connecticut online sellers and e-commerce brands

Call our Stamford office(203) 327-4311

Home / Case studies

Case studies

Hypothetical examples of how each strategy can change the tax bill for online sellers and e-commerce brands, shown before and after with 2026 federal and Connecticut figures.

Results at a glance

Reconciling a $186,000 Form 1099-K removed $8,700 of overstated tax

Hypothetical case study | Reconciling a $186,000 Form 1099-K from Etsy | Strategy: Reconcile Form 1099-K to your books

A hypothetical married couple in Norwalk, where one spouse runs an Etsy shop and the other earns $120,000 of W-2 wages.

The situation

The shop's 2026 Form 1099-K reports $186,000 of gross payments. Its books show $27,800 of Etsy fees and ads and $41,000 of cost of goods sold, and the couple's first draft of Schedule C deducts both from the 1099-K gross. That draft misses two items inside the gross: $9,400 of refunds issued to customers and $14,200 of sales tax that Etsy collected and remitted as the marketplace.

The approach

Reconciling the 1099-K to the books bridges the form's gross figure to what the shop actually kept. Schedule C still reports the full $186,000 as gross receipts, which matches the form for the IRS matching program, and then deducts the refunds and the marketplace sales tax along with the fees and product costs. Profit falls from $117,200 to $93,600, which lowers income tax, self-employment tax and Connecticut tax.

Before and after

2026, married filing jointly, first draft and reconciled returnBeforeAfter
Gross payments on Form 1099-K$186,000$186,000
Refunds and marketplace sales tax deducted$0$23,600
Schedule C profit$117,200$93,600
Federal adjusted gross income$228,900$207,000
Federal income tax$27,900$24,000
Self-employment tax$16,600$13,200
Connecticut income tax$11,800$10,400
Total tax$56,300$47,600

2026 federal and Connecticut tax overstated by the unreconciled draft: $8,700

Trade-offs and limits

  • The before column shows a common reporting error, not a planning choice. The reconciliation applies no special rule. It makes the return match what the shop kept.
  • The deductions hold up only with records behind them, such as the refund history and Etsy's report of the sales tax it collected.
  • Reporting only net deposits instead of the gross is a different error, and it can trigger an IRS matching notice even when the profit figure is right.
  • Connecticut receives a copy of the same 1099-K, and its income tax starts from federal AGI, so the correction carries through to the state return.
  • Bookkeeping and return preparation costs aren't included.

Assumptions

  • Married filing jointly, standard deduction, no other income. The couple's itemized deductions would be smaller than the standard deduction.
  • Figures for the shop come from the worked example in the Form 1099-K guide.
  • The QBI deduction is 20% of Schedule C profit less the deductible half of self-employment tax. Taxable income is below the $403,500 threshold, so no wage limit applies.
  • Self-employment tax is 15.3% of 92.35% of profit. Combined wages and self-employment earnings stay under $250,000, so no additional Medicare tax applies.
  • 2026 federal brackets (Rev. Proc. 2025-32) and Connecticut rates, including the 2% phase-out and benefit recapture.
  • Figures are rounded to the nearest $100.

This case study is hypothetical. The client and the figures are illustrations based on 2026 federal and Connecticut tax rules, not an actual client's results, and your own results will depend on your facts.

Collecting sales tax in two new states kept $21,200 from coming out of a brand's own funds

Hypothetical case study | A Shopify brand with nexus in two neighboring states | Strategy: Map your sales tax nexus

A hypothetical Shopify brand in Shelton that sells home goods through its own website and on Amazon.

The situation

In 2025 the brand's website sales into Massachusetts and New Jersey each passed $100,000 for the first time, though it was registered to collect sales tax only in Connecticut. For 2026 it expects $180,000 of website sales shipped to Massachusetts and $150,000 shipped to New Jersey. Amazon collects tax on the Amazon orders as the marketplace facilitator, but the website orders are the brand's responsibility.

The approach

A nexus review compares sales by state with each state's threshold. Both states require a remote seller to collect once its sales into the state exceed $100,000 in the current or prior year, so the brand has nexus in both for all of 2026. It registers with both states in January 2026 and sets its store to charge 6.25% on Massachusetts orders and 6.625% on New Jersey orders, so customers pay the tax at checkout instead of the brand paying it later out of its margin.

Before and after

2026 sales tax on website ordersBeforeAfter
Website sales shipped to Massachusetts$180,000$180,000
Website sales shipped to New Jersey$150,000$150,000
Massachusetts tax not collected from customers (6.25%)$11,300$0
New Jersey tax not collected from customers (6.625%)$9,900$0
Sales tax owed from the brand's own funds$21,200$0

2026 sales tax the brand would otherwise owe from its own funds: $21,200

Trade-offs and limits

  • The table covers 2026 only. Website sales made after the brand crossed each threshold may also be taxable, and that amount, with any interest and penalties, isn't included.
  • New Jersey also counts 200 or more separate transactions. The brand may have met that test before its sales passed $100,000, so its New Jersey exposure may begin before 2025.
  • Voluntary disclosure programs typically limit the look-back period and waive penalties on past periods, but interest is still owed, and a seller generally can't apply after a state has contacted it.
  • The after column assumes the same orders with tax added at checkout. Collecting tax raises the price customers pay, which may affect sales.
  • Registering adds returns to file in each state. Filing costs and any sales tax software aren't included.
  • Tax paid from the brand's own funds would generally be deductible for income tax, which lowers the net cost of not collecting. That effect isn't shown.
  • A full review also checks where Amazon stores the brand's inventory, because inventory in a state can create nexus regardless of sales.

Assumptions

  • The brand's products are taxable in both states, and orders ship free, so there are no separate delivery charges.
  • Massachusetts: 6.25% rate and a threshold of more than $100,000 of sales in the current or prior taxable year (M.G.L. c. 64H, §§2 and 34).
  • New Jersey: 6.625% rate and a threshold of more than $100,000 of gross revenue or 200 or more separate transactions in the current or prior calendar year (N.J.S.A. 54:32B-3.5, New Jersey Division of Taxation, Sales and Use Tax and Remote Sellers pages).
  • The statewide rate applies to every order.
  • Sales into other states and the brand's Connecticut sales tax aren't part of this comparison.
  • Figures are rounded to the nearest $100.

The people and numbers in this example are hypothetical. They apply 2026 federal and Connecticut tax rules to simplified facts, so a real return could come out differently, and professional fees aren't included.

The books method for inventory saved a seller $105,800 of 2026 tax

Hypothetical case study | A $4 million seller's year-end inventory | Strategy: Choose the right inventory method

A hypothetical married couple in Danbury whose S corporation sells kitchenware online and has $4 million of 2026 receipts.

The situation

The business starts 2026 with no stock on hand, buys $1.6 million of inventory during the year, sells goods that cost $1.3 million, and ends the year with $300,000 of stock. Its books record inventory purchases as expenses when paid. It has no financial statements that track inventory, takes no physical counts, and reports no inventory to a lender or its owners, but its tax return has been deducting only the cost of goods sold. One spouse draws a $200,000 salary, and the S corporation pays $500,000 of W-2 wages in all.

The approach

Average gross receipts are well under the $32 million test, so §471(c) lets the business follow the inventory method in its books. After the change, filed on Form 3115, the return deducts all $1.6 million of 2026 purchases, so the $300,000 still on the shelves is deducted in 2026 instead of when it sells. Connecticut starts from federal AGI, so the state follows the same timing.

Before and after

2026, married filing jointlyBeforeAfter
Cost of goods sold deducted$1,300,000$1,600,000
S corporation income passed through$700,000$400,000
Federal adjusted gross income$900,000$600,000
Federal income tax$192,300$109,000
Connecticut income tax$62,000$39,500
Total income tax$254,300$148,500

2026 federal and Connecticut income tax deferred: $105,800

Trade-offs and limits

  • This is a deferral. The $300,000 would otherwise be deducted in 2027 as those goods sell, so later taxable income is higher by the same amount. That tax stays deferred only while year-end stock stays at that level, and it comes back when inventory falls or the business is sold.
  • The method holds only if the books genuinely expense purchases. If its financial statements, inventory counts, or reports to a lender or owners track inventory, it must follow those records, and the 2026 deduction would be about $1.3 million.
  • Books that don't track inventory give weaker margin and stock information for running the business.
  • Lower profit also cuts the QBI deduction from $140,000 to $80,000, which the federal tax figures reflect.
  • When the deferral reverses, the tax could be at a higher or lower rate than in 2026.
  • The cost of preparing Form 3115 isn't included.

Assumptions

  • Married filing jointly, standard deduction, no other income. At these incomes the SALT cap is $11,900 or less, so their itemized deductions would be smaller.
  • Inventory figures come from the worked example in the inventory guide. With no stock on January 1, 2026, the method change carries no §481(a) adjustment.
  • The business isn't a tax shelter, and its average gross receipts for 2023 through 2025 are under $32 million.
  • The S corporation's other expenses, including its W-2 wages, are the same both ways. It doesn't elect the Connecticut PET.
  • The QBI deduction is 20% of S corporation income. Taxable income is above $553,500, the top of the phase-in range, but 50% of W-2 wages exceeds 20% of qualified business income, so the wage limit doesn't reduce it.
  • S corporation income isn't subject to self-employment tax, and the owner materially participates, so no net investment income tax applies.
  • 2026 federal brackets (Rev. Proc. 2025-32) and Connecticut rates, including the 2% phase-out and benefit recapture.
  • Figures are rounded to the nearest $100.

This is an illustration, not a client result. It uses 2026 federal and Connecticut rules and simplified facts. Some strategies defer tax rather than eliminate it. Get advice for your own situation before acting.

An S corp and a Solo 401(k) saved a Shopify owner $22,800 of 2026 tax

Hypothetical case study | A $220,000 Shopify business as an S corp with a Solo 401(k) | Strategy: S corp plus Solo 401(k)

A hypothetical single owner of a Shopify store in Fairfield that nets $220,000 a year and has no employees.

The situation

The owner has run the store as a sole proprietor with no retirement plan, so self-employment tax applies to 92.35% of the $220,000 profit. The owner is under 50, rents, and takes the standard deduction.

The approach

The business elects S corporation status and pays the owner a $90,000 salary, which is subject to payroll tax, while the remaining profit passes through free of self-employment tax. Through a Solo 401(k), the owner defers $24,500 of salary and the S corporation contributes 25% of salary, $22,500, for $47,000 in total. The salary, the employer's half of payroll tax and the employer contribution all come out of the business income that qualifies for the QBI deduction, which falls from $37,900 to $20,100.

Before and after

2026, singleBeforeAfter
Solo 401(k) contributions$0$47,000
Federal adjusted gross income$205,600$166,100
QBI deduction$37,900$20,100
Federal income tax$29,000$23,800
Self-employment or payroll tax$28,800$13,800
Connecticut income tax$11,800$9,200
Total tax$69,600$46,800

Reduction in 2026 federal, payroll and Connecticut tax, partly a deferral: $22,800

Trade-offs and limits

  • The two moves have separate effects. On its own, the S election saves about $9,400. Payroll tax falls by $15,000, but federal income tax rises by $5,000 and Connecticut tax by $600, because the QBI deduction shrinks and the employer's share of payroll tax is a smaller deduction than half of self-employment tax. That saving is permanent only while the salary stays reasonable for the work the owner does. A salary the IRS considers too low can be recharacterized, with back payroll tax and penalties.
  • The other $13,400 comes from the $47,000 of 401(k) contributions, which lower federal income tax by $10,200 and Connecticut tax by $3,200. That part is largely a deferral. Withdrawals are taxed federally, and Connecticut's subtraction for 401(k) income phases out between $75,000 and $100,000 of federal AGI for single filers.
  • The plan doesn't depend on the S election. As a sole proprietor, the owner could adopt the same Solo 401(k) and contribute up to about $65,600, the $24,500 deferral plus 20% of profit after the deduction for half of self-employment tax.
  • Social Security tax now applies to the $90,000 salary instead of up to $184,500 of self-employment earnings, so future Social Security benefits can be lower.
  • If the business hires an employee who becomes eligible, the plan must cover that employee, which changes its cost.
  • Payroll service fees, the separate S corporation return, unemployment taxes on the salary and the 0.5% Connecticut Paid Leave contribution withheld from it aren't included.
  • The S corporation doesn't elect the Connecticut PET here. That election is modeled in a separate case study.

Assumptions

  • Single filer under 50, standard deduction, no other income. Figures for the business come from the worked example in the S corp guide.
  • The $24,500 deferral is pre-tax, not Roth. The employer contribution is 25% of W-2 salary.
  • Before the election, self-employment tax includes the 0.9% additional Medicare tax on earnings above $200,000. After it, payroll tax is the employee's and employer's 7.65% each on the $90,000 salary.
  • Taxable income is below the $201,750 QBI threshold for single filers both ways, so no wage limit applies.
  • 2026 federal brackets (Rev. Proc. 2025-32), the $184,500 Social Security wage base, and Connecticut rates, including the 2% phase-out and benefit recapture.
  • Figures are rounded to the nearest $100.

Hypothetical example. The facts are simplified and the figures follow 2026 federal and Connecticut law. Actual savings vary with each taxpayer's circumstances and can differ from the amounts shown.

Raising a too-low S corp salary saved a couple $4,600 of 2026 tax, net

Hypothetical case study | An S corp salary set too low for the QBI wage limit | Strategy: Protect the 20% QBI deduction

A hypothetical married couple in Ridgefield, where one spouse owns an S corporation that earns $650,000 before the owner's salary.

The situation

The business uses a 3PL warehouse and contractors, so the owner's salary is its only W-2 payroll, and it owns no depreciable property that would raise the limit. To keep payroll tax down, the owner takes a $100,000 salary. The couple's taxable income is above $553,500, the top of the 2026 phase-in range for joint filers, so the QBI deduction can't exceed 50% of the business's W-2 wages.

The approach

With a $100,000 salary, the wage limit caps the deduction at $50,000, well below 20% of the business income. Raising the salary to $180,000 lifts the limit to $90,000. The higher salary and payroll tax reduce qualified business income, but 20% of it, $91,200, still exceeds the new limit, so the deduction rises by $40,000. The larger deduction saves more federal income tax than the extra payroll tax costs. Connecticut doesn't allow the QBI deduction, so the state effect is small and comes only from the employer's payroll tax deduction.

Before and after

2026, married filing jointlyBeforeAfter
Owner's W-2 salary$100,000$180,000
20% of qualified business income$108,500$91,200
Wage limit: 50% of W-2 wages$50,000$90,000
QBI deduction allowed$50,000$90,000
Federal income tax$133,600$117,400
Payroll tax on salary, employer and employee$15,300$27,500
Connecticut income tax$43,300$42,700
Total tax$192,200$187,600

Net 2026 federal, payroll and Connecticut tax saved: $4,600

Trade-offs and limits

  • The margin is narrow. It depends on the couple staying above the phase-in range and on the business having no other W-2 payroll or depreciable property, either of which would raise the limit without a higher salary.
  • About $9,900 of the extra payroll tax is Social Security tax. It earns credits toward future benefits but isn't otherwise recovered.
  • A salary above about $181,700 would start to lower the deduction, because each added dollar of salary reduces qualified business income.
  • A higher salary also supports the position that the owner's pay is reasonable compensation, which the IRS expects S corporation owners to take.
  • Unemployment taxes on the salary and the 0.5% Connecticut Paid Leave contribution withheld from it aren't included.
  • A Solo 401(k) would change the figures, because the employer contribution lowers qualified business income. It isn't modeled here.

Assumptions

  • Married filing jointly, standard deduction, no other income. At this income the SALT cap is $10,000, so their itemized deductions would be smaller.
  • The $650,000 is before the owner's salary and the employer's 7.65% share of payroll tax. The S corporation has no retirement plan and doesn't elect the Connecticut PET.
  • With no qualified property, the alternative limit of 25% of wages plus 2.5% of property is lower than 50% of wages.
  • The owner materially participates, so no net investment income tax applies, and wages stay under the $250,000 additional Medicare tax threshold.
  • 2026 federal brackets and QBI thresholds (Rev. Proc. 2025-32) and Connecticut rates, including the 2% phase-out and benefit recapture.
  • Figures are rounded to the nearest $100.

No real client is described here. The case applies 2026 federal and Connecticut tax rules to an invented set of facts to show how the strategy works, and results differ from one taxpayer to the next.

Registering for UK VAT on time avoided a £1,000 to £3,000 late penalty

Hypothetical case study | A Shopify brand shipping directly to UK customers | Strategy: Plan for international sales and suppliers

A hypothetical Shopify brand in Trumbull that began shipping orders from Connecticut directly to customers in Great Britain in 2026.

The situation

The brand sells standard-rated home goods through its own website, and every UK order is £135 or less. It expects £60,000 of UK checkout receipts in 2026 at its US prices converted to pounds. It isn't registered for UK VAT and charges none.

The approach

On direct sales of £135 or less shipped into Great Britain, the seller must charge UK VAT at the point of sale, and a business based outside the UK must register for VAT regardless of its sales level. Registering doesn't make the VAT go away. If the brand charges no VAT, UK law treats the price it collected as already including VAT, so one-sixth of its £60,000, or £10,000, is owed at the same checkout prices either way. What registering before the first UK sale avoids is the penalty for registering late, which for a failure that HMRC finds and that isn't deliberate is 10% to 30% of the unpaid VAT, or 20% to 30% once 12 months have passed since the VAT was due.

Before and after

2026 UK VAT and late-registration penalty at the same checkout prices, in pounds sterlingBeforeAfter
UK checkout receipts£60,000£60,000
UK VAT owed, one-sixth of receipts£10,000£10,000
Penalty for registering late, 10% to 30% of the VAT£1,000 to £3,000£0
UK VAT and penalty paid from the brand's receipts£11,000 to £13,000£10,000

UK late-registration penalty avoided, before interest: £1,000 to £3,000

Trade-offs and limits

  • Registering doesn't lower the VAT. At the same checkout prices, the brand pays £10,000 either way. Raising UK prices to pass the VAT on to customers is a pricing decision, and its effect on sales isn't modeled.
  • The penalty depends on how HMRC learns of the failure and how fully the brand cooperates. It can be reduced to nil if the brand tells HMRC unprompted within 12 months, and it can be higher if the failure is deliberate.
  • Late-payment interest on the VAT isn't included.
  • Registration brings UK VAT returns and records. Their cost, and any fee for a UK agent, isn't included.
  • Selling through an online marketplace moves the obligation. For orders of £135 or less, the marketplace charges and accounts for the VAT.
  • Orders to Northern Ireland and to EU countries follow different rules.
  • The US income tax effect isn't shown. VAT the brand bears would generally be deductible as a business expense, but a penalty paid to HMRC generally wouldn't be (IRC §162(f)).

Assumptions

  • All orders ship from Connecticut to consumers in Great Britain, none to VAT-registered businesses, and each order is £135 or less.
  • The goods are taxed at the 20% standard rate (GOV.UK, VAT rates).
  • Overseas sellers must register for UK VAT regardless of taxable turnover and charge VAT at the point of sale on direct sales of £135 or less (GOV.UK, Register for VAT, and VAT and overseas goods sold directly to customers in the UK).
  • When no VAT is charged, the price collected is treated as including VAT, so the VAT is 20/120 of it (Value Added Tax Act 1994, s. 19(2)).
  • In the before column, HMRC finds the failure and it isn't deliberate. A prompted, non-deliberate failure to notify carries a penalty of 10% to 30% of the unpaid VAT if HMRC prompts the disclosure within 12 months of the VAT being due, and 20% to 30% after that (HMRC factsheet CC/FS11). The table's range spans both.
  • Figures are in pounds, because UK VAT and penalties are charged in pounds, and are rounded to the nearest £100. At the IRS's 2025 yearly average rate of 0.759 pounds per dollar, the £10,000 of VAT is about $13,200 and the penalty about $1,300 to $4,000. The dollar cost depends on the exchange rate when each payment is made.

This case study is hypothetical. The client and the figures are illustrations based on 2026 federal and Connecticut tax rules, not an actual client's results, and your own results will depend on your facts.

Electing Connecticut's PET saved an online seller $3,100 in 2026

Hypothetical case study | Electing the PET for a $200,000 S corporation | Strategy: Get Connecticut sales tax and the PET right

A hypothetical married couple in Westport, where one spouse runs a home-goods brand as an S corporation and the other earns $400,000 of W-2 wages.

The situation

The S corporation sells $900,000 a year, $600,000 on Amazon with FBA and $300,000 through its Shopify store. It holds a Connecticut sales tax permit, Amazon collects the tax on Amazon orders, and the store charges 6.35% on orders shipped to Connecticut addresses, shipping included, about $3,200 a year. After the owner's $120,000 salary, the S corporation earns $200,000.

The approach

Electing the pass-through entity tax for 2026 has the S corporation pay 6.99% of its $200,000, about $14,000, and gives the couple a refundable Connecticut credit for 87.5% of it, about $12,200. The S corporation deducts the PET, so the couple's federal AGI falls by the full amount without running into the SALT cap. Connecticut doesn't require an add-back, so their Connecticut income falls too, and the net state cost is about $800: the uncredited 12.5% less the tax saved at their 6.9% rate.

Before and after

2026, married filing jointlyBeforeAfter
S corporation income after the owner's salary$200,000$186,000
Federal adjusted gross income$720,000$706,000
Federal income tax$164,300$160,400
Connecticut income tax, after the PET credit$49,600$36,400
PET paid by the S corporation$0$14,000
Total income tax$213,900$210,800

2026 federal and Connecticut income tax saved by the PET election: $3,100

Trade-offs and limits

  • The election is annual and irrevocable. It's made on a timely filed Form CT-1065/CT-1120SI, which for 2026 is due March 15, 2027, or September 15, 2027, with an extension. It can't be made on an amended return.
  • The PET also lowers the business income that qualifies for the QBI deduction, cutting that deduction by about $2,800, which the federal tax figures include.
  • The result depends on the couple's federal position. At their income the SALT cap is $10,000, so their own Connecticut tax brings no federal benefit. A couple who itemize with state and local taxes under the cap would gain much less and could come out behind.
  • Electing entities generally must make estimated PET payments during the year, which moves cash out earlier.
  • The federal deduction depends on timing. A cash-method S corporation deducts the PET in the year it's paid, and the IRS hasn't addressed payments made before the election, which comes with the return filed in 2027.
  • Sales tax is a separate obligation. Because the business is in Connecticut, it has owed tax on its Shopify orders from its first sale, regardless of the $100,000-and-200-sales test for remote sellers.
  • The cost of preparing Form CT-PET isn't included.

Assumptions

  • Married filing jointly, standard deduction, no other income. At this income the SALT cap is $10,000, so their itemized deductions would be smaller.
  • Sales figures and the $200,000 of S corporation income come from the worked example in the Connecticut guide. The salary and the spouse's wages are added for this case.
  • Connecticut AGI stays between $690,000 and $1,000,000 both ways. In that range the benefit recapture for joint filers is a flat $5,900, so the marginal Connecticut rate is 6.9%, as in the guide. A further recapture applies above $1,000,000.
  • The owner's salary is the S corporation's only W-2 payroll. Taxable income is above $553,500, and 50% of that salary exceeds 20% of qualified business income, so the QBI deduction is 20% of S corporation income.
  • All $200,000 is in the PET base, because the business and its owner are in Connecticut. The S corporation pays the full PET by December 31, 2026. The credit is less than the couple's Connecticut income tax, so none of it is refunded.
  • The owner materially participates in the business, so its income isn't subject to the net investment income tax.
  • Payroll taxes, including the additional Medicare tax on the couple's wages, don't change and aren't shown.
  • 2026 federal brackets (Rev. Proc. 2025-32) and Connecticut rates, including the 2% phase-out and benefit recapture.
  • Figures are rounded to the nearest $100.

The people and numbers in this example are hypothetical. They apply 2026 federal and Connecticut tax rules to simplified facts, so a real return could come out differently, and professional fees aren't included.

Find out where you owe sales tax and what you could keep.

In a consultation, we look at your sales by state, Forms 1099-K, and last return, estimate whether an S corp and Solo 401(k) could lower your tax, and tell you where you may need to register.

(203) 327-4311

Request a free consultation

The first consultation is free, with no obligation.

Call (203) 327-4311Free consultation